Company Reviews

Main Street America is owned by American Family Insurance. With ‌essential add-ons available, you can easily customize your home insurance policy to best suit your unique needs with Main Street America.

Indiana Farmers is an established insurer providing homeowners insurance in Indiana and Illinois. Founded in 1877, this insurer has received solid financial ratings and mostly positive customer reviews.

Selective Insurance Group is a New Jersey-based insurance company that offers homeowners insurance in 15 states. Their policies come with a few extras and there are plenty of options to customize your coverage. Customers reviews report affordable premiums.

Cincinnati Insurance is a large insurance company offering homeowners insurance in 46 states. Their policyholders report fair prices and Cincinnati is financially stable. This insurer is ranked as 20the largest insurance company in the US.

Headquartered in Birmingham, Alabama, Infinity Insurance was a national provider of car insurance. When it was founded in 1955, it was known as Dixie Insurance in Aniston, Alabama. It expanded quickly in the South and was eventually known as Infinity.  Company Overview The company was acquired by Pennsylvania Company in 1991, which is American Premier ... Read more

Wellington Insurance offers several named-peril homeowners and dwelling fire insurance policies. They operate only in Texas and are known to insure higher-risk, older, and coastal homes that are declined by other providers.

Goodville Mutual is a Pennsylvania-based insurance company that offers homeowners insurance in 8 states. Their policies include a lot of free perks and they are able to insure many types of homes. They get positive reviews from clients about their rates, claims process and overall experience.

Donegal Insurance Group offers homeowners insurance in 24 states. They have earned a good reputation for having competitive insurance premiums, fair claims process, and pleasant customer service.

Founded in 1921, State Auto insurance company offers home, condominium, renters, landlord, and auto insurance in 28 states. Their home insurance policies come with many extras that you don't normally see from other insurers. According to multiple sources, State Auto is able to provide affordable rates and has earned stable financial ratings.

Olympus home insurance has a tight focus on the Floridian homeowners market. Their site is full of helpful information and preparedness plans for tough weather specific to Florida natives. This may be in part why their customers and professionals have such a great outlook on the company. Overall, Olympus is deemed as very reliable as proven by their response during Irma and most clients say they had a positive experience with the company.

Horace Mann specializes in offering insurance for professors and educators. They offer homeowners insurance among other products in 45 states. Horace Mann got a lot of positive reviews and also complaints about claims process.

Oregon Mutual is an independent mutual insurance company providing casualty and property coverages for individuals, businesses, and families. Today, Oregon Mutual provides home insurance, auto insurance, and business insurance policies in Oregon, Idaho, California, and Washington. Basic home, business, and personal auto insurance policies are sold through their over 800 independent insurance agents across the four ... Read more