Advertising Disclaimer

Cheap Massachusetts Home Insurance & Best Companies

Read Time: 9 mins

Our team is devoted to helping homeowners make the right coverage choices. We adhere to strict editorial guidelines to maintain the accuracy and relevance of our content. This article may feature our affiliate partners who provide us with compensation; however, our reviews remain independently formed. For further details, please refer to our Editorial Policy.


On average, Bay Staters are paying $2,102 every month on homeownership costs. There are 3 million homes in the Bay State, 62% of which are occupied by owners.

  • Population: 6,902,149
  • Average value of homes that’s occupied by owners: $352,600
  • Households: 2,585,715
  • Average household income: $74,167
  • High school grad or higher, percent of people age 25 years +: 90%
  • Average travel time to work: 29 min

The average premium amount was sourced from the latest data of the Insurance Information Institute, and the statistical data from the U.S. Census Bureau.

Boston and Cambridge are among the most desirable places to live in Massachusetts, known for great schools, beautiful nature, and booming job industry. Massachusetts is a northeastern U.S. state in New England named after a tribe. Like many other states, MA is familiar with devastating natural disasters such as hurricanes, storms, and wildfires. In 2011, Hurricane Irene became the reason for severe damages in 14 states of the US, including Massachusetts. According to Wikipedia, damage estimates throughout affected areas in the U.S. totaled about $13.5 billion, marking Hurricane Irene as one of the most expensive hurricanes to ever hit the country. In particular, to MA, most of the damage was seen in Western Massachusetts and Hill Towns.

Compare home insurance quotes
Use our free comparison tool to compare rates from best providers in your area

When disaster strikes, your home or business will face a lot of trouble and damages, and you would have to spend your savings to recover from such disasters. In this state, you can be affected by brutal winters, storms, and floods caused by hurricanes and wildfires. Therefore, you need to get proper coverage for the damages you may face due to extreme weather conditions.

There are many top-rated companies providing coverage for damages caused by floods or wildfires, so to ensure that you are getting the best deal around, shop around and compare quotes from different providers. Our free online tool will help you by providing a list of home insurers in your area. To learn more about premiums in MA, keep reading below.

MA Premiums vs nationwide

We gathered the mean home insurance premiums from data recorded by Insurance Information Institute (III). In 2016 (latest available data), the average premium rate in Massachusetts was $1,451 annually, which translates to $121 every month. There is a difference of $259 between the national average of $1,192, landing Massachusetts in the 9th spot for most expensive home insurance premiums across all 51 states.

These rates can differ according to the value of your property, the age of your home, the area or location of your property, and the amount of coverage you require. Homeowners insurance is more commonly regulated in Massachusetts than in any other state in the US.

As a Massachusetts homeowner, you understand there are four seasons with various weather conditions. These conditions at times can be so extreme that you stand to lose your home which you have invested so much on. However, this does not render you helpless. Home insurance covers many catastrophes that might strike your home like tornadoes, fire, and burglary. The cover pays for: repairs that your home may need, injuries to anyone else who might have suffered from the damage, the effects to other properties during the damage, and even temporary residence if need be. With insurance, you will live all year long without fear of fluctuating conditions.

Average Massachusetts Home Insurance Premiums

Monthly average$121$115$109.5
Annual average$1,451$1,379$1,314
National annual average$1,192$1,173$1,132
Source: The annual average premiums came from the Insurance Information Institute’s latest recorded data. We calculate the estimated monthly insurance costs based on the data provided.

Popular Insurance Companies In Massachusetts

According to Massachusetts’ official government site, the state is likely to experience tropical storms and hurricanes, urging residents, tourists, and businesses to prepare accordingly. People living and working in hurricane evacuation zones are encouraged to have an emergency plan. Hurricane and tropical cyclone season in MA usually happen from late August to September. Due to this and many other factors such as heavy snowfalls in winter, a unique homeowners insurance market has been created in the state.

Following are the leading companies in Massachusetts, based on III’s table of top 10 insurers in written direct premiums and market share holdings. Their ratings by AM Best, S&P, and JD Power have also been mentioned below, to give a clear picture of the company’s financial backing and customer satisfaction history. We are not able to review all of the companies in MA that offer home insurance, therefore, it’s worth digging deeper into additional companies to find great coverage and the best deal for you and your home.


The headquarters of MAPFRE Insurance is in Webster, Massachusetts, and it was founded in 1972. This company was started as Commerce Group but was acquired by MAPFRE in 2008. This company has the largest homeowners insurance market share in MA with a 13.5 percent share.

MAPFRE received an A (Excellent) from AM Best for its solid financial strength and received 3 (About average) out of 5 Power Circle Ratings from JD Power. The ratings predict that MAPFRE is financially stable and can pay all the bills in your time of need. The add-on feature that you will like about this company is its extended replacement cost. Hence, when the value of repairs and maintenance increases after severe storms or floods, it will not bother you when the prices are comparatively higher for building materials due to increased demand.

This company offers you to choose from Commerce and Citation policies. Commerce policies are the standard ones, while Citation policies are for preferred customers. Commerce policyholders can get up to 20% off on their premiums when they bundle home and auto insurance.

MAPFRE has a very user-friendly website with an emergency contact that works 24/7.

Liberty Mutual

This company has been serving its customers since 1912, and its headquarters is in Boston, Massachusetts. It scored a rating of A (Excellent) from AM Best and an A (Strong) from S&P. Furthermore, the JD Power survey shows its overall customer satisfaction got a score of 3 (About average) out of 5 Power Circle Ratings. In 2017, Liberty Mutual had a 10.6 percent market share in MA’s home insurance scene.

Liberty Mutual offers many discounts along with insurance policies which can save you a lot on premiums. This company provides discounts if you have protective devices installed in your home, if you have purchased a new house, or if you go for bundle offers like home and auto policies together.

Along with coverage for your property, you can have add-on protection for your valuables, water backup, and inflation protection. You can buy policies from Liberty Mutual online, but for that purpose, you must know certain details about your home like its construction and renovation. Filing a claim with this company is as simple as buying an online service.


Safety is the third largest insurance provider in Massachusetts with a 7.2 percent home insurance market share. This company was founded in 1979 in Boston, Massachusetts. Although JD Power has not rated this company, AM Best gives it an A (Excellent) for displaying strong financials.

There is no option to obtain online quotes, so you would have to go to call an agent to help guide you through the rates, policies, and coverage you can have. You can be eligible for the discounts by installing burglar, fire, and smoke alarms, by bundling auto and home insurance, and via e-payments.

Massachusetts Home Insurance Companies: Market Share and Summary of Ratings

RankInsurerMarket Share %AM BestS&PJD Power
2Liberty Mutual10.6AA3
7Amica Mutual4.0A+NR5
10Vermont Mutual3.8A+NRNR
NR: Not rated
Source: Insurance Information Institute, AM Best, S&P, JD Power

Homeowners can choose any of the companies mentioned above to cover their properties as per their requirements, but you will need an agent to get a quote as most of these companies don’t sell policies online. It’s to note here, that an insurer we did not mention may also provide you with great coverage. One thing to keep in mind is that flood insurance is not included in most standard insurance policies. There is an option to sign up for it separately through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP).

Compare home insurance quotes
Use our free comparison tool to compare rates from best providers in your area

If you are having trouble finding coverage for your property in areas that are more prone to disasters, you can go for the FAIR Plan from the Massachusetts Property Insurance Underwriting Association (MPIUA) which is a non-profit organization.

Cover Benefits

Once you get coverage for your home, you are automatically assigned a local agent who understands your policy. This agent will explain to you what your policy covers, as well as the claims you can make under this policy. The agent is also well-equipped with tools and resources to help you understand the possible preventive practices available. The agent is from your local area, so you will be able to access them quickly and ask any questions that will be bothering you.

Diversity Of Coverage

Most homes have a standard insurance cover. The policy covers your home, family, and your belongings. A Massachusetts insurance cover gives you an option for additional cover. Under this option, you can choose to protect other valuables that you deem necessary. Examples of properties you can include are your garden, musical instruments, and sports equipment.

Shopping in Newbury Street in Back Bay, Boston via GIPHY

Tips on how to save money

Welcome Discount

This discount is an automatic way of saving. As a new customer, you are given up to 10% discount on your home insurance premium. Even though this applies to the first two years of being insured, it is a great way of saving right from the start.

Sign Early

Do not wait until your current cover expires. Sign up for a new policy before the new one expires. This way can save you up to 10% of the total premium.

Safety Discount

As much as insurance can shoulder your losses, you can as well do something on your side. Ensure you take some initiatives to secure your home on your own. You can install theft cameras or some fire safety devices. By adopting these actions, you have the potential to save up to 15% of your home insurance premium.

Easy Pay Plan

When you pay from your savings account, you will save up to 5%. Setting up automatic payments will also see you keep the same percentage in your pocket. In addition to saving some money, it is also convenient.

Massachusetts home insurance premiums are on the higher end, so it makes sense to shop around to find the cheapest rates. If you put in the time to do research and compare quotes, along with finding out money saving tips and discounts, it’s possible to find affordable coverage in MA.

Get Cheap Home Insurance
Compare quotes from the top insurance companies in your area to find the cheapest plan


United States Census Bureau  

Insurance Information Institute

Consumers Advocate


For more assistance, please contact your local state department of insurance:

Massachusetts Division of Insurance

Check Out Massachusetts’ Neighboring States

Thank You for Visiting HOIC